Over Memorial Day weekend I decided to test out two coffee ice cream recipes to see how they were different. I made Jeni's Spendid coffee ice cream (as blogged by
Cookie&Kate) and David Lebovitz's recipe (which you can find
here)
What's the difference? Well, Jeni's ice cream doesn't require eggs, in fact the recipe was quite interesting because it required corn starch and cream cheese, which I found intriguing. David L's was a much more familiar ice cream with a custard base (IE, you rely on egg yokes to emulsify the ice cream into that thick creaminess we all love). I really wanted to see how the ice cream worked without eggs, because I never know what to do with all those extra egg whites sitting in my frig homeless and lacking telos.
I used the same coffee (Wegmans' decaf) to make both, and really didn't tamper with the recipes (except that I used honey instead of agave or light corn syrup in Jeni's recipe)
Jeni's
The first thing that I find interesting is that it does not freeze quickly. At all. I have made her chocolate and her coffee and neither one is ready to eat same day (anybody want a syrupy milkshake, by all means, eat it a couple hours out of the ice cream maker). Next day, it's like ice cream. This one came out a little icier than the other, but I'm not sure I would have noticed if I wasn't eating them side by side. It also came off as sweeter than the other recipe, which I found curious.
 |
| Jeni on the L, DL on the right |
David's
The big hole in the picture above is where Zorro stuck his finger for his own amusement (and probably to see me squawk at him). As usual, David delivers a flavorful ice cream of creamy texture and deepening flavor.
 |
| Again, Jeni on the left, DL on the right |
I think that personally, I'll stick to David's coffee ice cream, though if I ever don't have enough eggs I may mash up the two recipes and see if I can get more of the deepening coffee flavor in the egg-less recipe.